Papa Don’t Peach Blush

Product: Papa Don’t Peach BlushBrand: Too FacedRequested By: popRequest 🔮What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: Too many beauty enthusiasts have “hit pan” on this beloved color for it to be discontinued. Loved by many and desperately missed by many more.…

Liquid Glitter Eyeshadow Disco Queen

Product: Disco Queen Liquid Glitter Eyeshadow Brand: E.L.FRequested By: popRequest 🔮 What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: A true standout, this product combined a lightweight gel with unapologetically chunky glitter for a look that felt bold, fun, and completely unmatched. While…

Chocolate Bar Eye Shadow Palette

Product: Chocolate Bar Eye Shadow PaletteBrand: Too FacedRequested By: popRequest 🔮 What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: Voted for by over 750 users on Reddit. This dreamy, chocolate-scented eyeshadow palette is the one that got away.