Papa Don’t Peach Blush

Product: Papa Don’t Peach BlushBrand: Too FacedRequested By: popRequest 🔮What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: Too many beauty enthusiasts have “hit pan” on this beloved color for it to be discontinued. Loved by many and desperately missed by many more.…

Format Blush

Product: Format BlushBrand: MACRequested By: popRequest 🔮What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: It was a rosy color with such a warm, natural finish!

Moonchild Glow Kit

Product: Moonchild Glow KitBrand: Anastasia Beverly HillsRequested By: popRequest 🔮 What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: Beauty enthusiasts rushed to TJ Maxx for their last opportunity to snag this iconic holographic palette before it disappeared for good.

Chocolate Bar Eye Shadow Palette

Product: Chocolate Bar Eye Shadow PaletteBrand: Too FacedRequested By: popRequest 🔮 What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: Voted for by over 750 users on Reddit. This dreamy, chocolate-scented eyeshadow palette is the one that got away.

Killawatt Foil Freestyle Highlighter

Product: Killawatt Foil Freestyle HighlighterBrand: Fenty BeautyRequested By: Pickles  What Beauty Enthusiasts Miss About It: The buildable formula. It worked for both subtle daytime glow and full glam when needed.